Tajikistan HRITF Impact Evaluation
P128567
Other Health
DDI_TJK_2018_HRBFIE-FEL_v01_M_WB
Development Economics Data Group
2019-09-12
Nesstar Publisher
Gil Shapira
Version 01 (September 2019).
TJK_2018_HRBFIE-FEL_v01_M
--
--
Health Results Based Financing Impact Evaluation 2018
Health Facility Endline Survey
HRBFIE-FEL 2018
TJK_2018_HRBFIE-FEL_v01_M
Gil Shapira
Damien de Walque
Mahbuba Mstafaevna
Fatima Gaibova
Saodat Mirsaburova
Wezi Msisha
Ha Ngyuyen
Kate Mandeville
Mutriba Latypova
Sabrina Qandenova
Sarvinoz Barfieva
Rouselle Lavado
Tashrik Ahmed
Huihui Wang
Aneesa Arur
Jeanette Walldorf
Nesstar Publisher
Health Results Innovation Trust Fund
Gil Shapira
Impact Evaluation Survey
Tajikistan
Three districts in the Sughd region and four districts in the Khatlon region were selected to implement the program. All Rural Health Centers in these seven districts are covered by the program. Nine additional districts (two in Sughd and seven in Khatlon) were selected as control districts. The selection of the control districts was guided by geographical proximity to treatment districts and similarity in terms of number of health facilities and doctors per capita. The districts were also selected such that the number of RHCs in treatment and control groups in each region would be similar.
Sample survey data [ssd]
Zerkalo Analytics
Computer Assisted Personal Interview [capi]
The Committee on Ethics of the Ministry of Health and Social Protection reviewed the study design, fieldwork protocols and the instruments and granted ethical clearance for the study on October 24th, 2014. The Health Results Innovation Trust Fund survey instruments were adapted to the Tajik context. Additional modules were developed to correspond to the project focus on NCD outcomes on top of the MCH outcomes. Representatives of the Ministry of Health, Zerkalo, and members of the World Bank team conducted several field visits to health facilities to inform the adaptation of the survey instruments. The instruments were pretested three times between August and October 2014, before the training of the field team. A local firm, Zerkalo, was selected through an international competitive procurement process to manage all aspects of the data collection. Figure 6.2., in the attached report located in “external resources”, summarizes and illustrates how data collection was organized for the baseline and endline surveys. Identical instruments were used with few adjustments.
Users of the data agree to keep confidential all data contained in these datasets and to make no attempt to identify, trace or contact any individual whose data is included in these datasets.
Gil Shapira
- Licensed datasets, accessible under conditions
The user of the data acknowledges that the original collector of the data, the authorized distributor of the data, and the relevant funding agency bear no responsibility for use of the data or for interpretations or inferences based upon such uses.
f1_hh_facility.NSDstat
Health facility assessment questionnaire. Data collected at the health facility level. The following modules are included: general, administration, human resources, staff member roster, services, general health management information systems (HMIS), health services utilization based on HMIS, user fees, direct observation, direct observation equipment, catchment area.
150
1137
Nesstar 200801
f1_rhc_facility.NSDstat
Health facility assessment questionnaire for rural health centers. Data collected at the health facility level. The following modules are included: general, administration, human resources, staff member roster, laboratory, services, general health management information systems (HMIS), health services utilization based on HMIS, user fees, autonomy, direct observation, direct observation equipment, drug and vaccine storage and availability, and catchment area.
215
1990
Nesstar 200801
f2_hh_healthworker.NSDstat
Health worker individual survey. Data collected at the individual health worker level. The following modules are included: general, training, hours, salary, other compensation, supervision, supplemental income, who well-being index, and health worker satisfaction.
279
210
Nesstar 200801
f2_rhc_healthworker.NSDstat
Health worker individual survey conducted in rural clinics. Data collected at the individual health worker level. The following modules are included: general, training, hours, salary, other compensation, supervision, supplemental income, who well-being index, health worker satisfaction, personal drive, and innovation.
842
257
Nesstar 200801
f4a_adult_exit.NSDstat
Adult exit interview. Data collected at the individual patient level. The following modules are included: identification, patient travel and expenditure, patient satisfaction, safety and trust, questions about the household, and household assets.
3225
144
Nesstar 200801
f4c_child_exit.NSDstat
Child (under age 5) exit interview. Data collected at the individual patient level. The following modules are included: identification, treatment and counselling, patient travel and expenditure, patient satisfaction, safety and trust, questions about the household, and household assets.
3225
220
Nesstar 200801
f21a_adult_observation.NSDstat
Direct observation of adult patients. Data collected at the individual patient level. The following modules are included: adult patient.
3225
78
Nesstar 200801
f21c_child_observation.NSDstat
Direct observation of child patients. Data collected at the individual patient level. The following modules are included: child patient.
3225
193
Nesstar 200801
f22_clinical_vignettes.NSDstat
1116
227
Nesstar 200801
Facility_code
150
0
110102
312603
225134.913
Province name
150
0
1
SUGHD
43
2
KHATLON
107
District name
150
0
11
11
12
9
13
11
14
8
15
4
21
11
22
8
23
10
24
5
25
8
26
5
27
11
28
14
29
12
30
16
31
7
Treatment arm
149
1
0
29
1
24
2
26
3
21
4
23
5
26
Sysmiss
1
Pbf treatment
150
0
0
79
1
71
Cqi treatment
150
0
0
101
1
49
Crc treatment
150
0
0
103
1
47
Survey date
150
2010-01-02
2018-07-08
2010-01-02
1
2018-03-12
1
2018-03-13
7
2018-03-15
1
2018-03-16
1
2018-03-17
7
2018-03-19
1
2018-03-28
4
2018-03-29
4
2018-03-30
5
2018-03-31
1
2018-04-02
4
2018-04-03
1
2018-04-04
2
2018-04-05
2
2018-04-06
3
2018-04-09
4
2018-04-10
2
2018-04-11
4
2018-04-12
2
2018-04-13
3
2018-04-14
3
2018-04-16
3
2018-04-17
3
2018-04-18
1
2018-04-19
4
2018-04-20
3
2018-04-21
5
2018-04-24
3
2018-04-25
2
2018-04-26
5
2018-04-27
2
2018-04-28
2
2018-04-29
1
2018-05-01
2
2018-05-02
2
2018-05-03
1
2018-05-04
2
2018-05-05
2
2018-05-07
5
2018-05-08
1
2018-05-10
3
2018-05-11
3
2018-05-14
2
2018-05-15
4
2018-05-16
1
2018-05-17
1
2018-05-18
1
2018-05-19
1
2018-05-22
2
2018-05-23
2
2018-05-24
2
2018-05-28
2
2018-05-29
1
2018-05-30
1
2018-05-31
2
2018-06-01
1
2018-06-02
1
2018-06-05
2
2018-06-08
1
2018-06-09
3
2018-06-15
1
2018-07-08
1
Begin survey time
150
0
10:00
1
10:05
1
10:06
1
10:11
1
10:12
1
10:13
1
10:15
1
10:16
1
10:23
1
10:24
1
10:26
1
10:27
1
10:28
1
10:39
1
10:40
1
10:41
1
10:44
1
10:46
1
10:47
1
10:51
1
10:56
1
10:59
1
11:02
1
11:14
1
11:15
1
11:17
1
11:24
2
11:26
1
11:29
1
11:30
1
11:31
1
11:37
1
11:46
1
11:48
1
11:54
1
12:00
1
12:10
1
12:13
2
12:14
1
12:18
1
12:23
1
12:24
1
12:25
2
12:27
1
12:28
1
12:34
1
12:42
1
12:51
1
12:58
1
13:02
1
13:07
1
13:11
1
13:26
1
13:31
1
13:42
1
13:49
1
13:50
1
14:08
1
14:11
1
14:12
1
14:20
1
14:22
1
14:24
1
14:39
1
14:49
1
15:01
1
15:06
1
15:16
1
15:24
1
15:29
1
15:35
1
15:38
1
15:39
1
16:25
1
16:50
1
5:20
1
6:55
1
7:28
1
7:53
1
8:08
1
8:15
1
8:25
1
8:26
2
8:28
1
8:29
1
8:31
1
8:34
1
8:35
1
8:38
1
8:40
1
8:42
1
8:43
2
8:46
2
8:49
1
8:50
1
8:53
1
8:55
2
8:56
1
8:58
1
9:02
1
9:04
2
9:05
1
9:06
1
9:10
2
9:11
2
9:12
1
9:13
1
9:14
1
9:15
1
9:17
1
9:19
1
9:24
2
9:28
1
9:30
1
9:31
1
9:32
1
9:33
1
9:34
1
9:36
1
9:37
2
9:39
2
9:40
2
9:44
3
9:46
1
9:48
1
9:49
2
9:51
1
9:53
2
9:55
1
9:57
3
End survey time
150
0
10:00
1
10:03
1
10:04
1
10:09
1
10:10
1
10:13
1
10:14
1
10:15
1
10:17
1
10:20
1
10:21
1
10:33
2
10:35
2
10:37
2
10:38
1
10:39
1
10:41
1
10:42
2
10:49
1
10:59
1
11:00
1
11:03
1
11:04
1
11:05
1
11:06
1
11:07
3
11:10
2
11:15
1
11:16
2
11:17
2
11:22
1
11:24
1
11:27
1
11:28
1
11:29
2
11:31
2
11:34
1
11:38
1
11:40
1
11:41
1
11:42
1
11:44
1
11:45
1
11:46
1
11:47
1
11:49
1
11:50
1
11:54
1
11:55
1
11:56
1
11:59
2
12:03
2
12:04
1
12:06
2
12:12
1
12:14
2
12:16
2
12:17
1
12:19
1
12:31
1
12:32
1
12:33
1
12:34
1
12:35
1
12:39
1
12:40
2
12:41
1
12:48
1
12:51
1
13:01
1
13:09
1
13:14
2
13:16
1
13:20
1
13:26
1
13:28
1
13:29
1
13:31
1
13:32
1
13:33
1
13:39
1
13:41
1
13:49
1
13:55
1
13:57
1
14:01
2
14:06
1
14:14
1
14:17
1
14:23
1
14:34
1
14:38
1
14:51
2
14:55
1
14:56
1
14:57
1
15:02
1
15:11
1
15:14
1
15:18
1
15:22
1
15:29
1
15:37
1
15:46
1
16:00
1
16:12
1
16:26
1
16:27
1
16:33
1
16:44
1
16:52
1
16:58
1
17:02
1
17:34
1
17:52
1
18:04
1
18:54
1
6:21
1
8:06
1
8:39
1
8:56
1
9:17
1
9:32
1
9:33
1
9:40
1
9:47
1
9:49
1
9:52
3
S1.Q1.01. Are you in charge of this facility today?
Respondent: Head of the health facility or his/her deputy if absent or unavailable.
S1.Q1.01. Are you in charge of this facility today?
150
0
1
YES
142
2
NO
8
S1.Q1.02. Are you authorized to represent this facility?
Respondent: Head of the health facility or his/her deputy if absent or unavailable.
S1.Q1.02. Are you authorized to represent this facility?
150
0
1
YES
149
2
NO
1
S1.Q1.03. What is your job title at this facility?
Respondent: Head of the health facility or his/her deputy if absent or unavailable.
S1.Q1.03. What is your job title at this facility?
150
0
1
Head of RHC
120
2
Family Physician
1
3
Obstetrician/Gynecology
0
4
Clinical intern/junior doctor
0
5
Midwife
2
6
Family Nurse
13
7
Feldsher
14
96
Other
0
S1.Q1.04. Is this facility a district hospital, a health center or a health post
Respondent: Head of the health facility or his/her deputy if absent or unavailable.
S1.Q1.04. Is this facility a district hospital, a health center or a health post?
150
0
1
District hospital
0
2
Health center
0
3
Health House
150
96
Other
0
When was the last major investment in the infrastructure?
Respondent: Head of the health facility or his/her deputy if absent or unavailable.
S1.Q1.05. When was the last major investment in the infrastructure?
143
1989-08-15
2018-05-15
1989-08-15
1
2000-01-15
3
2000-02-15
3
2000-03-15
1
2000-04-15
1
2000-08-15
1
2002-01-15
1
2002-08-15
1
2003-08-15
1
2005-07-15
1
2005-08-15
1
2005-10-15
1
2006-08-15
1
2008-06-15
1
2008-07-15
1
2008-10-15
1
2008-11-15
1
2008-12-15
1
2009-02-15
1
2009-05-15
1
2009-08-15
1
2009-09-15
2
2010-03-15
1
2010-08-15
1
2010-09-15
1
2011-08-15
1
2011-09-15
2
2011-11-15
1
2011-12-15
1
2012-01-15
1
2012-03-15
1
2012-07-15
1
2013-05-15
1
2013-08-15
3
2013-09-15
2
2014-01-15
1
2014-03-15
2
2014-06-15
2
2014-08-15
1
2014-09-15
1
2014-11-15
1
2015-03-15
5
2015-04-15
2
2015-05-15
2
2015-06-15
3
2015-08-15
2
2015-09-15
3
2016-02-15
2
2016-03-15
1
2016-04-15
2
2016-06-15
1
2017-01-15
1
2017-02-15
2
2017-03-15
3
2017-04-15
2
2017-05-15
1
2017-06-15
1
2017-07-15
1
2017-08-15
5
2017-09-15
2
2017-10-15
3
2017-11-15
4
2017-12-15
12
2018-01-15
6
2018-02-15
1
2018-03-15
19
2018-04-15
4
2018-05-15
1
Start of outpatient care - weekdays
Respondent: Head of the health facility or his/her deputy if absent or unavailable.
Interviewer: Record the time in military manner, e.g., if it starts at 7am, record 0700. If it ends at 7pm, record 1900.
150
0
26100000
28800000
28590000
Start of outpatient care - saturday
Respondent: Head of the health facility or his/her deputy if absent or unavailable.
Interviewer: Record the time in military manner, e.g., if it starts at 7am, record 0700. If it ends at 7pm, record 1900.