Type | Thesis or Dissertation - Master of Arts in Psychological Research |
Title | Parenting programmes in South Africa: investigating design and evaluation practices |
Author(s) | |
Publication (Day/Month/Year) | 2012 |
URL | http://open.uct.ac.za/bitstream/handle/11427/11562/thesis_hum_2012_wessels_i.pdf?sequence=1 |
Abstract | Parenting programmes have been shown to have wide-ranging benefits, including the prevention of behavioural and emotional problems in children as well as child maltreatment. The majority of research conducted on parenting programmes is from high-income countries, with little available knowledge on programmes within low- and middle-income countries, such as South Africa. This study sought to identify, as far as possible, the range of parenting programmes offered in South Africa and investigate their design and evaluation practices in relation to best practices. It also sought to identify high-quality programmes which could be scaled-up successfully. This is particularly important in South Africa due to the country’s high rates of violence and child maltreatment. Through the use of snowball and convenience sampling procedures, 21 programmes located across the country were recruited into the study. Included programmes were group-based and located in either the non-profit or commercial sector. They contained specific parenting components or curricula aimed at reducing negative parenting, teaching positive parenting strategies or improving parent-child attachment and relationships. Information on programmes was collected via telephonic and face-to-face interviews with programme staff. The main focus areas of the interview included: needs assessment; programme design and content; facilitator training, supervision and delivery; monitoring and evaluation; and replicability and scalability. Data was analysed using frequency counts and thematic analysis. Programme materials were also collected from programmes, and their content was reviewed and assessed. The study revealed that local programmes tended not to be based on solid theoretical frameworks and often had limited or no monitoring and evaluation processes in place. Local programmes would be strengthened by incorporating practices associated with programme effectiveness. None of the participating programmes were at a point where they could be scaledup successfully. This was largely because programmes did not have evidence of efficacy and effectiveness. The study concludes with recommendations for practice and research, which include the importance of building the evidence base on parenting programmes in low- and middle-income countries. |